Callaway Herringbone Full Zip Vest vs Callaway Men's Quilted Puffer Golf Vest

Both are Callaway polyester golf vests with a full zip, banded collar and sun protection. The Herringbone is a flat midweight layer with moisture wicking and no pockets; the Quilted Puffer adds front-panel insulation, a partial lining and front pockets. Owners rate the Puffer 4.6 out of 5 across 251 ratings and call it warm and lightweight. Buy the Herringbone for a smooth, low-bulk layer under a jacket or on mild days. Buy the Puffer for cold mornings and for pockets.

• Choose the Herringbone vest if you want a thin, moisture-wicking layer that sits flat under another jacket and you don't need pockets.
• Choose the Quilted Puffer vest if you want real warmth on the front, front pockets and a lining, and you don't mind a bulkier layer.