Members Only Packable Windbreaker vs Portwest Pakka Men's Packable Jacket

Buy the Members Only windbreaker if you want a hooded, lined jacket that looks like a racer jacket and packs to envelope size. Buy the Portwest Pakka if you want a plain, unlined shell made from recycled fabric that packs into its own pouch and has an adjustable waist. Owners rate the Members Only highly and praise the fit and looks, though some say it runs small, so size up. The Portwest is the more utilitarian pick with fewer style claims.

• Choose the Members Only windbreaker if you want a hood, a polyester lining and a retro racer-jacket look that folds into its back pocket.
• Choose the Portwest Pakka if you want a simple unlined shell in recycled fabric with an adjustable waist and its own stuff pouch.