Men's Waterproof Insulated Winter Jacket vs The North Face McMurdo Parka

The North Face McMurdo is the better-built parka: a two-layer waterproof membrane, a two-way zipper with velcro storm flap, and down-and-synthetic fill that holds warmth in serious cold. The Melrose Avenue Label jacket is the practical pick for big sizes and budget-minded everyday wear, with a 3-in-1 design and a detachable hood. Reviewers rate the Melrose fit true to size and praise its warmth, but the McMurdo wins on weather protection and hardware.

• Choose the Melrose Avenue Label jacket if you wear a size above XXL or want a 3-in-1 coat with a detachable hood for everyday winter wear.
• Choose The North Face McMurdo if you face real cold and wet weather and want a proven parka with a proper waterproof membrane and down fill.