Which boot is better for roofing work?

The BP Clothing moc-toe. Its leather upper, wedge sole and wide fit suit standing on slopes and ladders all day. The Eddie Bauer adds a steel toe but uses a synthetic upper.

Do I need the steel toe?

If your site requires impact protection or you handle heavy materials, yes. The Eddie Bauer Tradesman is the only one of the two with a steel toe.

The BP Clothing boot should. Goodyear welt construction lets a cobbler resole it, and leather outlasts synthetic uppers. The Eddie Bauer is a replace-it boot.

Which is more comfortable for long shifts?

Both use cushioned insoles. The BP Clothing adds a wide fit and a wedge sole that spreads pressure; the Eddie Bauer uses an EVA insole aimed at foot fatigue.

Are either of these insulated for winter?

Only the BP Clothing boot is listed as insulated. The Eddie Bauer Tradesman has no insulation, so it is a three-season boot.

Is the BP Clothing boot worth it over the Eddie Bauer?

It depends on price and whether you need a steel toe. Check the current prices for both on this page; the leather and welt construction favor the BP Clothing boot if the prices are close.

BP Clothing 655BK Men's Work Boots vs Eddie Bauer Tradesman Work Boots

Buy the BP Clothing moc-toe if you want a leather boot with a wedge sole and wide fit for roofing, concrete and long standing shifts. Buy the Eddie Bauer Tradesman if you need a steel toe for impact protection on a job site. No price was given for either boot, so compare store prices on this page before you decide.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.