Merit Five Minute Morning vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
Buy the Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit if you want a compact, travel-ready lip and eye set in the famous nude-pink Pillow Talk shade. Buy the Merit Five Minute Morning if you want a full face-and-lip routine in one customizable set with clean, vegan formulas. The Charlotte Tilbury kit costs far less: $34.39 at its lowest as of November 2, versus $177.00 for Merit as of October 31.
Ask our shopping agent
Merit Five Minute Morning
Choose the Merit Five Minute Morning if you want a complete customizable morning routine covering complexion, cheeks, lips, lashes and brows in one set.
Pros
- One set covers the whole face, lips, lashes and brows
- Customizable: pick The Minimalist or The Uniform and choose shades
- Vegan and cruelty-free, free of 72 potentially acne-triggering ingredients
- Hydrating, buildable light-to-medium coverage
Cons
- Costs $177.00, roughly five times the Charlotte Tilbury kit
- No SPF unless you pick The Uniform
- Full-size pieces are bulkier for travel
What separates them
| Merit Five Minute Morning | Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $177.00 as of October 31 | $34.39 as of November 2 |
| What it covers | Complexion, cheeks, lips, lashes and brows | Lips and eyes only |
| Number of items | 7 pieces | 5 pieces |
| Customization | Choose between The Minimalist or The Uniform and pick shades | Fixed contents in one Pillow Talk shade |
| Formula focus | Vegan, cruelty-free, free of 72 acne-triggering ingredients | Free of sulfates, fragrance, parabens and minerals |
| Finish | Light-to-medium, buildable, hydrating glow | Matte, soft-focus finish |
| Sizes | Full-size set | Travel-size lip products, full-size Eyes to Mesmerise |
Price history
$177.00$34.39
- Merit Five Minute Morning: lowest $177.00 on Oct 31 at meritbeauty.com; $177.00 on Nov 2.
- Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit: lowest $34.39 on Nov 2 at eBay.
Prices at every store
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
- AmazonCheck price at Amazon
- eBayCheck price at eBay
Specs compared
| Spec | Merit Five Minute Morning | Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit |
|---|---|---|
| Color | Umber, Amber, Apres, Archival, Bespoke | Nude-pink |
| Form Type | Stick, Balm, Brush, Mascara, Oil | Mascara, Liquid (liquid blush) |
| Texture Type | Lightweight formula | Smooth, Creamy (liquid blush) |
| Buildable Coverage | Yes | Buildable |
| Free Of | 72 potentially acne-triggering ingredients | sulfates, fragrance, minerals, parabens |
| Body Part Use | Lip, Brow, Cheek, Lash | Lips, Eyes |
| Primary Effect | Volumizing, Highlighting | Soft-focus finish |
| Is A Palette | No | No |
| Is A Set | Yes | Gift set, Kit |
| Multipack |
What reviewers say
Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
Pillow Talk is one of Charlotte Tilbury's most popular shade ranges, and owners of the lip liner and Matte Revolution lipstick generally rate the color and wear highly. The Eyes to Mesmerise cream shadow draws mixed feedback, with praise for blendability and complaints about creasing on oily lids.
Pros
- Lip Cheat is widely liked for shaping lips without a harsh line
- Matte Revolution color described as a flattering my-lips-but-better nude
- Eyes to Mesmerise blends easily with fingers
- Compact mirror and travel sizes make it easy to carry
Cons
- Cream eyeshadow can crease or fade on oily eyelids
- Matte lipstick can feel dry after several hours
- Travel-size lip products run out quickly for daily use
- Some find the nude-pink shade too light or too warm for deeper skin tones
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a full everyday face?
- The Merit Five Minute Morning. It includes complexion, cheek, lip, lash and brow products, while the Charlotte Tilbury kit covers only lips and eyes.
- Is the Charlotte Tilbury kit worth the lower price?
- Yes if you want the Pillow Talk lip and eye look in a travel format. At $34.39 as of November 2 it costs far less than Merit's $177.00 as of October 31.
- Which is better for travel?
- The Charlotte Tilbury kit. Its lip products are travel size and it includes a compact mirror, while Merit ships full-size pieces.
- Which has cleaner ingredients?
- Both avoid common irritants. Merit is vegan and free of 72 potentially acne-triggering ingredients; Charlotte Tilbury is free of sulfates, fragrance, parabens and minerals.
- Which lasts longer?
- Merit, on quantity. Its seven full-size pieces outlast Charlotte Tilbury's travel-size lip products, though the Eyes to Mesmerise pot is full size.
- Can I customize either set?
- Only Merit. You choose between The Minimalist and The Uniform and select shades; the Charlotte Tilbury kit has fixed contents.
More comparisons
- Cult Classics Full Face Kit (6 PC) vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
- Merit Five Minute Morning vs Nars Endless Orgasm Vault
- Cult Classics Full Face Kit (6 PC) vs Merit Five Minute Morning
- Complete Baked Starter Kit (8 PC) vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
- Nars Endless Orgasm Vault vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
- Sephora Favorites vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit
- Makeup Made Simple Kit (3PC) vs Charlotte Tilbury Pillow Talk Icons On the Go Kit