Michael Kors Hooded Bib Snorkel Parka vs Ash & Reid Men's Field Coat

Buy the Michael Kors parka if you face real winter cold, snow or ski trips; its 20-degree warmth rating, quilted bib and faux-fur hood make it the heavier, more protective coat. The Ash & Reid field coat is the better pick for mild-to-chilly days and a cleaner, less bulky look, with a hidden hood and brushed pocket linings. Owners of the Kors coat praise warmth and style but report it runs large and some zipper and snap issues; Ash & Reid buyers mostly cite warmth and a sharp fit.

• Choose the Michael Kors parka if you need a long, insulated coat rated for around 20-degree weather and want a fur-trimmed hood and quilted bib for skiing, camping or travel in cold climates.
• Choose the Ash & Reid field coat if you want a mid-length, regular-fit coat for chilly but not freezing days that looks sharp without bulk and has a hidden hood and warm-lined pockets.