Miele Guard L1 Electro vs Miele Guard S1 Canister Vacuum
Both are bagged Miele canisters with sealed ComfortFit bags and AirClean exhaust filters, so hygiene and filtration are close. The Guard L1 is the larger, heavier machine: 17 lb, a 0.92 gal bag, a 36 ft hose and a 39.4 ft operating radius, with four power modes and a Comfort handle with an integrated dust brush. The Guard S1 is the compact one: about 11 lb, a 3.5 L bag and a 33 ft radius, aimed at homes with mostly hard floors and a few flat rugs. Owners rate the L1 well (4.5 from 98 ratings) and the S1 very highly on a small sample (5 from 14); the L1 suits whole-home carpet cleaning, the S1 suits apartments and stairs.
- Choose the Guard L1 if you have wall-to-wall carpet, pets, and a large floor plan where a long hose and big bag mean fewer socket changes and fewer bag swaps.
- Choose the Guard S1 if you live in an apartment or condo with mostly hard floors and flat rugs, and you want a light canister you can carry up stairs and store on a shelf.
Prices
- Miele Guard L1 Electro: $874.30 at Abt Electronics (checked today)
- Miele Guard S1 Canister Vacuum: $470.00 at Amazon (last seen Nov 16)
- Difference: the Miele Guard S1 Canister Vacuum is $404.30 cheaper than the Miele Guard L1 Electro at the latest prices (Nov 16 and Nov 17)

