StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set vs Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

Buy the 18-color set if you need a full working palette for starting out or everyday painting. Buy the Army Painter metallics set if you mainly want a range of metallic tones and a brush to go with them. The 18-color set covers matte base colors plus two metallics, with 20 ml dropper bottles and a glass mixing bead in each. The Army Painter set is 10 metallic paints in 18 ml bottles with two steel mixing balls, a basecoating brush, a guide and stickers. Owners of the 18-color set praise its coverage, smooth flow and true matte finish, but note most colors need more than one coat and the set has two yellows. The Army Painter set has fewer ratings and they say little about the paint itself.

  • Choose the 18-color acrylic set if you are starting a collection and need matte base colors, two metallics and precise dropper bottles in one box.
  • Choose the Army Painter Fanatic metallics set if you want a spread of metallic tones plus a brush and guide, and already have your matte colors.

Prices

  • 18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set: $24.99 at goldenmaple (last seen Nov 21)
  • Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set: $34.95 at Galactic Toys & Collectibles (last seen Nov 21)
  • Difference: the 18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set is $9.96 cheaper than the Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set at the latest prices (Nov 21)
M
Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints

18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set

Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints

4.9(20 ratings)
$24.99at goldenmapleChecked 8 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit goldenmaple
Pros
  • 18 colors cover base coating and detail work in one box
  • Dropper tips give precise, clean dispensing
  • Glass bead speeds up shaking and mixing
  • Dries hard and does not reactivate with water
  • Works with brush or airbrush and thins with water
Cons
  • Most colors need more than one coat over dark primer
  • Formula is less creamy than some brands
  • Nozzles can ooze paint for a while after pouring
  • Two yellows, with no bone or mid-tone brown
The Army Painter
Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

5(20 ratings)
$34.95at Galactic Toys & CollectiblesChecked 9 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Galactic Toys & Collectibles
Pros
  • 10 metallic paints in one set
  • Two steel mixing balls in every bottle
  • Includes a basecoating brush, painting guide and stickers
  • Water-based and non-toxic
Cons
  • Metallics only, so you still need matte colors
  • 18 ml bottles hold less than the rival's 20 ml
  • Few owner reports on how the paint itself performs

What separates them

18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint SetArmy Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set
Paint range16 matte colors plus Metallic Gray and Metallic Gold10 metallic paints only
Bottle size20 ml per bottle18 ml per bottle
Mixing aidOne glass bead per bottleTwo stainless steel mixing balls per bottle
FinishSatin to semigloss by brush, flat by airbrushMetallic
Included extrasBottles only, with child-resistant capsBasecoating brush, painting guide and sticker sheet
ReactivationDoes not reactivate with water once dryWater-based acrylic, standard reactivation
Coat countMost colors need more than one coat, especially over dark primerNot enough owner feedback to say
Color selection gapsTwo yellows; no off-white or mid-tone brownNo matte colors at all

Prices at every store

18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set

  • goldenmapleNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $24.99Checked 8 h ago
    Visit goldenmaple
Prices and history →

Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

  • Galactic Toys & CollectiblesNew

    In stockReturn policy

    $34.95Checked 9 h ago
    Visit Galactic Toys & Collectibles
Prices and history →

Specs compared

Spec18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint SetArmy Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set
Paint typewater-based acrylicnon-toxic, water-based
Number of colors18—
Bottle volume20 ml—
Bottle typedropper bottles—
Color breakdown16 matte colors plus Metallic Gray and Metallic…—
Dry finish (brush)satin, maybe even semigloss—
Dry finish (airbrush)flat—
Dry timewithin minutes—
ReactivationWILL NOT reactivate with water or itself—
Dispenser tipvery fine, thin dispenser tip—
Paint count—10 x 18 ml Metallic paints
Bottle size—18ml
Show all 18 specsShow fewer specs
Spec18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint SetArmy Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set
Mixing balls—two high-grade stainless steel Mixing Balls
Included guide—Painting Guide
Included extras—Sticker sheet
Included brush—Basecoating Brush
Package dimensions—9x6x1.25"
Model—WP8069

What reviewers say

18-Color Miniature Acrylic Paint Set

  • 4.9 / 520 ratings

Buyers rate the set highly and call it a strong starter collection with vibrant colors and good metallics. They like the smooth, fine pigment, the clean dropper bottles and the fact that dry paint stays put under water. The main complaints are thin coverage and a finish that is less matte than advertised when brushed on undiluted.

What people mention
  • CoverageCriticisedBuyers say most colors need more than one coat, especially over dark primer.
  • ConsistencyMixedThe paint is smooth and mixes well with water, but some find it less creamy than other brands.
  • FinishMixedIt dries flat through an airbrush, but undiluted brush coats dry toward satin or semigloss rather than matte.
  • Dropper bottlesPraisedThe fine tips are precise and clean, though some nozzles oozed paint for a while after pouring.

Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

  • 5 / 520 ratings

Buyers rate the set 5 out of 5 and describe the paints as easy to use and high quality. Praise centers on the metallic finish and the included extras.

What people mention
  • Ease of usePraisedBuyers say the paints are easy enough for beginners to pick up and use straight away.
  • Paint qualityPraisedReviewers describe the acrylics as high quality and call the line the new gold standard for miniatures.
  • Set contentsPraisedBuyers like getting ten metallics plus a brush, guide and sticker sheet in one box.
  • Metallics onlyMixed

Questions and answers

Which set is better for a complete beginner?
The 18-color set. It gives you matte base colors, two metallics and a full palette to learn on. The Army Painter set is metallics only, so you would need matte paints as well.
Which has better metallics?
The 18-color set's two metallics get specific praise from owners. The Army Painter set offers 10 metallic tones, which is far more choice, but its ratings say little about the paint itself.
Do the paints last once opened?
Both use dropper bottles that limit air exposure. The 18-color set adds a glass bead and caps that press to open. The Army Painter set uses two steel mixing balls per bottle.
Is the Army Painter set worth stepping up to?
Only if metallics are what you need. It adds a brush, guide and stickers, but it does not replace a matte palette, so most painters end up owning both kinds of set.
Which is better for airbrush use?
The 18-color set is stated to dry flat through an airbrush and thins with water. The Army Painter set is water-based too, but its listing gives no airbrush guidance.
How many coats do the 18-color paints need?
Owners say most colors need more than one coat, especially over dark primer. Plan on two thin coats for solid coverage.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Nicpro 30 Colors Model Paint Set vs Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints
  • Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints vs Vallejo Model Air Acrylic Paint - Pale Green, 18 ml
  • Pro Acryl Paints (22ml Bottle) vs Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints
  • Acrylic Paint Set V2.0 for Wargame Miniatures vs Miniature Paint Set: 18 x 20ml Acrylic Paints
  • Nicpro 30 Colors Model Paint Set vs Army Painter Fanatic Metallics Paint Set

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best acrylic model paints for miniatures
The set covers metallic tones only, so painters still need separate non-metallic colors.