DealsBuying guidesBrandsStoresTermsPrivacydeal.ai apps

© Deal.ai Inc.

Deal.ai › Compare

Miranda 14 vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Both are Frye tall boots with a 14.5" calf, but they are different boots. The Melissa Button 2 WC is real vegetable-tanned leather with a leather lining and outsole and a 1" heel, so it wears and ages like a classic Frye. The Miranda 14 is vegan leather with a memory foam insole, a 2" block heel and a square toe, and it costs more. On November 3, 2026 the Melissa Button 2 WC is $124.00 at Dress Code and the Miranda 14 is $129.99 at Amazon. Buy the Melissa if you want leather and a low heel; buy the Miranda if you want a taller heel and a vegan upper.

Today the Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots costs $5.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

Frye
Miranda 14

Miranda 14

4.3· 6,447 ratings
$129.99at AmazonObserved at 8:14 AM
Visit store

Choose the Miranda 14 if you want a 2" block heel, a square toe and a vegan upper with a memory foam insole, and you are fine paying $129.99 at Amazon as of November 3, 2026.

Pros
  • Memory foam insole for out-of-the-box comfort
  • 2" block heel adds height without a thin stiletto
  • Square toe and scrunch shaft give a slouchy look
  • Vegan upper and lining suit shoppers avoiding animal leather
  • Wide calf version exists in the same style
Cons
  • Vegan leather will not patina or soften like real leather
  • TPR outsole is less repairable than leather
  • 12.5" shaft is shorter than the Melissa's 15.5"
  • Costs $5.99 more than the Melissa on November 3, 2026
Frye
Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

$124.00at Dress CodeObserved at 9:23 AM
Visit store

Choose the Melissa Button 2 WC if you want real leather, a leather lining and outsole, and a 1" heel, at $124.00 at Dress Code as of November 3, 2026.

Pros
  • Full leather upper, lining and outsole
  • 1" heel is easy to walk in all day
  • 15.5" shaft covers more of the leg
  • Antique silver hardware on the button detail
  • Cheaper: $124.00 at Dress Code on November 3, 2026
Cons
  • Leather outsole is slippery when new and wears faster on pavement
  • No memory foam or cushioned insole
  • Round toe and button style are more traditional
  • Dress Code page noted sold out or low stock

What separates them

Miranda 14Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
Upper materialVintage vegan tumbled leatherVegetable smooth leather
LiningVegan leatherLeather
OutsoleTPR (rubber-like)Leather
Heel height2" block heel1"
Shaft height12.5"15.5"
Toe shapeSquareRound
InsoleMemory foamStandard leather footbed
Price, November 3, 2026$129.99 at Amazon$124.00 at Dress Code

Price history

  • Miranda 14: lowest $129.99 on Nov 3 at Amazon.
  • Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots: lowest $178.00 on Nov 3 at eBay.

Prices at every store

Miranda 14

  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $129.99Free shippingObserved at 8:14 AM
    Visit store

Also available at

  • Frye & CoCheck price at Frye & Co
Prices and history →

Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

  • eBayNew

    In stock

    $178.00Free shippingObserved at 8:13 AM
    Visit store
  • PoshmarkNew

    In stock

    $178.00+ $6.49 shippingObserved at 8:13 AM
    Visit store
  • Dress CodeNew

    Availability unknownReturn policy

    $124.00Observed at 9:23 AM
    Visit store
  • AmazonNew

    Availability unknown

    As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.

    $229.98Free shippingObserved at 8:13 AM
    Visit store
All 4 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecMiranda 14Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
Shaft height12.5"15.5"
Calf circumference14.5"14.5"
Heel height2"1"
Toe shapeSquare toeRound toe
Upper materialVintage vegan tumbled leatherVegetable smooth leather
LiningVegan leather liningLeather lining
OutsoleTPR outsoleLeather outsole
Platform height10mm—
InsoleMemory foam—
ClosurePull on—
Shaft circumference—14 1/2"
Hardware—Antique silver hardware
Show all 13 specsShow fewer specs
SpecMiranda 14Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
Country of origin—Made in Mexico

What reviewers say

Miranda 14

With 4.3 out of 5 from 6,447 ratings, owners generally rate the Miranda 14 well, citing comfort and looks. Complaints tend to center on calf fit and the feel of the synthetic materials.

Pros
  • Comfortable right out of the box
  • Attractive tall silhouette
  • Easy to walk in despite the heel
Cons
  • Tight calf for some wearers
  • Vegan leather feels less premium than leather
  • Hard to pull on without a zip

Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Owners of the Melissa Button 2 generally praise the leather quality and classic look, but some note the stiff break-in and narrow calf fit. The leather sole is a common point of criticism for wet or icy conditions.

Pros
  • Supple, thick leather that softens with wear
  • Timeless riding-boot silhouette
  • Comfortable low heel for walking
Cons
  • Stiff at first and needs a break-in period
  • Calf runs narrow for some wearers
  • Leather sole lacks grip and durability

Questions and answers

Which is better for all-day walking?
The Melissa Button 2 WC. Its 1" heel and leather outsole are flatter and more stable than the Miranda's 2" block heel. The Miranda's memory foam insole is softer at first, but the higher heel tires feet sooner.
Which lasts longer?
The Melissa Button 2 WC. Real leather uppers and linings mold to the foot and can be resoled. Vegan leather and a TPR outsole on the Miranda 14 tend to crack and cannot be repaired the same way.
Is the Miranda 14 worth the extra money?
Only if you want the 2" heel, square toe and vegan materials. It is $129.99 at Amazon versus $124.00 for the Melissa at Dress Code on November 3, 2026, so the Melissa is both cheaper and leather.
Which fits a wide calf?
Both list a 14.5" calf circumference. The Miranda 14 also comes in a dedicated wide calf version, which gives more room than the standard Melissa Button 2 WC.
Which is better in rain or snow?
The Miranda 14. Its TPR outsole grips wet pavement better than the Melissa's leather outsole. Neither is a waterproof winter boot.
Do both have the same shaft height?
No. The Miranda 14 has a 12.5" shaft; the Melissa Button 2 WC has a 15.5" shaft, so it sits about 3" higher on the leg.

More comparisons

  • Frye Campus 14in Leather Wide Calf Boot vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Miranda 14 vs Frye Campus 14in Leather Wide Calf Boot
  • Frye Kate Harness Leather Boot vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots
  • Frye Veronica vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best Frye women's boots
  • Best Frye women's leather boots