Which is better for everyday walking?

The Melissa Button 2. Its 1-inch heel and flat profile are easier for long wear than the Kate Harness's 2-inch heel and platform. The Kate Harness's rubber sole does grip better on slick pavement.

Which boot is taller?

The Melissa Button 2. Its shaft is 15.5 inches with a 14.5-inch calf, against 11 inches and 14.3 inches for the Kate Harness. The Kate Harness sits closer to mid-calf on many wearers.

Is the Melissa Button 2 worth the savings?

At $124.00 at Dress Code versus $224.99 at ShopSimon as of November 3, 2026, yes if you want a flat riding boot. You give up the rubber sole and the harness detail, and the leather outsole needs more care.

Which has the better sole for rain or winter?

The Kate Harness. Its rubber sole handles wet sidewalks better than the leather outsole on the Melissa Button 2, which is slick when wet and wears faster.

Do both run in the same size?

Sizing data is limited for both. The Kate Harness measurements were taken from a size 6, and the Melissa Button 2 lists no size chart here, so check the store's return policy before ordering.

Frye Kate Harness Leather Boot vs Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots

Both are Frye leather pull-on boots, but they suit different shoppers. The Kate Harness is a knee-high statement boot with a 2-inch heel and harness hardware; the Melissa Button 2 is a quieter riding-style boot with a 1-inch heel and a leather outsole. At the latest prices, the Melissa Button 2 is far cheaper at $124.00 at Dress Code as of November 3, 2026, versus $224.99 at ShopSimon for the Kate Harness. Buy the Kate Harness if you want the taller, heeled look and can pay about $100 more; buy the Melissa Button 2 if you want a flat, classic boot at a lower price.

Today the Frye Melissa Button 2 WC Womens Leather Boots costs $100.99 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent