Modern 8-Tier Shoe Cabinet vs Asofer Shoe Cabinet with 2 Flip-Down Drawers

Buy the Modern 8-tier cabinet if you need to store a whole household's shoes in one tall unit. Buy the Asofer if you want a low, wide console for a hallway with only a few pairs and a spot for keys. The Modern cabinet holds far more and has adjustable shelves, but it is a tall MDF flat-pack that needs wall anchoring. The Asofer is shorter, sturdier on its four legs, and rated 4.6 from 127 owners, though its flip-down drawers suit flats and low shoes better than boots.

• Choose the Modern Shoe Cabinet if you have 20 or more pairs and a tall wall to fill, and you want adjustable shelves for boots and high-tops.
• Choose the Asofer if you want a low entryway console with a place for keys and hats, and you only need to tuck away a handful of pairs.