MSR Elixir 1 Backpacking Tent vs Featherstone Obsidian 1P Backpacking Tent
The MSR Elixir 1 is the better tent for most solo backpackers. It has a true rectangular floor that fits a wide pad, a larger vestibule, two-way zippers that close to one point, and all-metal corner hardware. The Featherstone Obsidian 1P is lighter and packs smaller, and its 20-denier Sil-Nylon with a 5000 mm coating is a serious fabric for the weight. Owners of the Elixir praise easy setup and durability; the Obsidian rates well but has a smaller, hexagonal floor and a single hubbed pole that flexes more in wind.
- Choose the MSR Elixir 1 if you want more floor space, a bigger vestibule and sturdier hardware, and you don't mind carrying a bit more weight.
- Choose the Featherstone Obsidian 1P if saving weight and packed size matters more than interior room, and you want a fully taped Sil-Nylon shelter.
Prices
- MSR Elixir 1 Backpacking Tent: $269.95 at Limber Grove (checked today)
- Featherstone Obsidian 1P Backpacking Tent: $65.00 at Featherstoneoutdoors (last seen Nov 10)
- Difference: the Featherstone Obsidian 1P Backpacking Tent is $204.95 cheaper than the MSR Elixir 1 Backpacking Tent at the latest prices (Nov 10 and Nov 16)

