My Texas House Monroe Nightstand vs Anya Woven Rattan 3-Drawer Nightstand

The Anya is the better pick for most shoppers. It scores higher with owners (4.9 vs 4.3) and its hand-woven rattan fronts and solid wood handles give it a more distinctive look than the Monroe's plain wood-composite build. The Monroe is the safer choice if you want a traditional brushed oak finish that blends into a classic bedroom. Both are flat-packed and need assembly, and both hold three drawers, so the decision comes down to style and finish rather than storage.

• Choose the My Texas House Monroe if you want a warm brushed oak traditional look that fits a classic bedroom and you prefer a straightforward painted-wood finish over woven texture.
• Choose the Anya Woven Rattan if you want a distinctive rattan-front piece with solid wood handles, a retro distressed finish and the stronger owner rating.