My Texas House Roan Swivel Accent Chair vs Reane Swivel Accent Chair

The Reane is the better chair for most shoppers. It offers three upholstery choices, a 350 lb weight capacity, a metal swivel mechanism and a multi-layer foam-and-spring seat, while the Roan gives you one brown polyester fabric and a sinuous spring seat on a solid wood frame. Owners of the Reane call it sturdy, comfortable and easy to assemble, though some say assembly ran long and the sit is firmer than expected. The Roan's 4.6 rating from 724 ratings is a deeper track record than the Reane's 4.8 from 32 ratings, so treat the Reane's score as promising but thin.

• Choose the My Texas House Roan if you want a squared-arm modern farmhouse look in brown or cream and prefer a proven rating across hundreds of owners.
• Choose the Reane if you want fabric or faux leather options, a higher weight capacity and a metal swivel base, and you don't mind some assembly.