Naomi Heart Cut Lab Diamond Engagement Ring vs Martha Stewart 2 Carat Heart Shape Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring Sterling Silver
The Naomi is the better-made, more wearable ring: a 0.50ct H/SI heart-cut diamond in recycled 925 silver with a 2mm band and a 6.3mm center stone, hallmarked and handcrafted. The Martha Stewart ring puts a much larger 2.0ct VS stone on the hand, but in sterling silver with little published detail on setting or band width. Buy the Naomi for a delicate everyday engagement ring; buy the Martha Stewart if a big, bold center stone is the whole point.
- Choose the Naomi if you want a delicate, well-specified solitaire with a certified-quality H/SI stone and a slim band you can wear daily.
- Choose the Martha Stewart if you want a large 2 carat heart-shaped stone as a statement ring and wear it occasionally.
Prices
- Naomi Heart Cut Lab Diamond Engagement Ring: $425.00 at The Diamond Store (checked today)
- Martha Stewart 2 Carat Heart Shape Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring Sterling Silver: $1,799.99 at Shop Simon (checked today)
- Difference: the Naomi Heart Cut Lab Diamond Engagement Ring is $1,374.99 cheaper than the Martha Stewart 2 Carat Heart Shape Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring Sterling Silver today

