Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag
Buy the Coach Brooklyn 28 if you want a soft, structured leather shoulder bag that holds its shape and fits a water bottle, phone and charger without bulk. Buy the Naomi if budget is the deciding factor: it is $63.00 at eBay as of November 4, 2026, versus $295.00 at Macy's for the Brooklyn 28. The Naomi is the cheaper everyday carry, but the Coach is the better-made bag and the one most shoppers will keep longer.
Today the Naomi Shoulder Bag costs $232.00 less at its best price.
Ask our shopping agent
Naomi Shoulder Bag
4.8Choose the Naomi if you want a leather-look shoulder or crossbody bag for under $70 and don't need a roomy, structured interior.
- Low price: $63.00 at eBay as of November 4, 2026
- Shoulder and crossbody wear in the Small size
- Internal zip pocket plus multifunctional pockets
- Detachable chain strap adds a dressier option
- Very high rating volume: 4.8 from 11,051 ratings
What separates them
| Naomi Shoulder Bag | Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | $63.00 at eBay as of November 4, 2026 | $295.00 at Macy's as of November 4, 2026 |
| Material | Faux leather body with pebbled finish (listing also states leather outer) | Leather |
| Size | Small: 9.5"W x 14"H x 5.5"D; also sold in Large and Oversized | 11.5"L x 8.75"H x 2.75"W |
| Carry options | Adjustable long strap plus detachable chain short strap; Small converts to crossbody | Single shoulder strap with 10.5" drop; no crossbody strap |
| Interior organization | One compartment, internal zip pocket, multifunctional pockets, unlined | Spacious single interior with one snap pocket |
| Structure | Unlined, soft body that slouches | Holds its shape |
| Closure | Magnetic snap |
Price history
- Naomi Shoulder Bag: lowest $63.00 on Nov 4 at eBay.
- Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag: lowest $295.00 on Nov 4 at Macy's.
Prices at every store
Naomi Shoulder Bag
- eBayNew
Availability unknownSold by thisorthat-7
$63.00Observed at 8:54 AM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$118.00Free shippingObserved Nov 3, 2026, 3:02 PM
Also available at
- Portland LeatherCheck price at Portland Leather
- Clothes Mentor North OlmstedCheck price at Clothes Mentor North Olmsted
- TreetCheck price at Treet
Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag
- Macy'sNew
In stock
$295.00Free shippingObserved at 9:54 AM - AmazonNew
Availability unknown
As an Amazon Associate, Deal.ai earns from qualifying purchases.
$295.00Free shippingObserved at 8:34 AM
Specs compared
| Spec | Naomi Shoulder Bag | Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag |
|---|---|---|
| Height | 14" (Oversized) | 8.75" |
| Width | 9.5" (Small) | 2.75" |
| Material | Faux Leather | — |
| Dimensions | 14 cm x 32 cm x 10 cm | — |
| Compartments | 1 compartment | — |
| Internal pocket | internal zip pocket | — |
| Other pockets | multifunctional pockets | — |
| Long strap | adjustable long strap | — |
| Short strap | detachable short strap (chain) | — |
| Pockets | multifunctional pockets | — |
What reviewers say
Naomi Shoulder Bag
The bag has a strong 4.8 rating from over 11,000 ratings, and owners mostly praise its look, light weight and comfortable shoulder strap. The most common complaints are the lack of pockets and the size of the Large and Oversized versions.
- Stylish V-shape design
- Lightweight but sturdy
- Comfortable over-the-shoulder fit
- Fits a canvas purse organizer well
- Few internal or external pockets
- Small size feels crowded
- Large size smaller than some expected
- Large and Oversized lack crossbody carry
Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag
With 581 ratings averaging 4.5 out of 5, owners mostly praise the leather, size and versatility. Complaints center on the strap and on limited organization.
Questions and answers
- Which is better for everyday carry?
- The Brooklyn 28 carries more without looking bulky and holds its shape, so it suits daily use better. The Naomi is lighter and cheaper but slouches and has a smaller usable interior in the Small size.
- Is the Coach worth $232 more?
- If you want real leather that keeps its shape for years, yes. If you change bags often or want a low-cost crossbody, the Naomi at $63.00 is the smarter buy.
- Which works as a crossbody?
- Only the Naomi, and only in the Small size, which has an adjustable long strap. The Brooklyn 28 has a single 10.5" shoulder strap and is not designed for crossbody wear.
- Which holds more?
- The Brooklyn 28. Its 11.5" x 8.75" x 2.75" body fits a water bottle, charger and phone. The Naomi Small is 9.5" wide and buyers say it feels crowded.
- Which lasts longer?
- The Coach. Its leather develops patina and holds structure; the Naomi is faux leather and unlined, so it wears faster with daily use.
- Which has better pockets?
- The Naomi has an internal zip pocket and multifunctional pockets. The Brooklyn 28 has just one interior snap pocket, which buyers call too few.
More comparisons
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Michael Kors Women's Jet Set Large East West Zip Camera Crossbody Bag
- Coach Brooklyn 28 Shoulder Bag vs NOTAG Crossbody Bag for Women Waterproof Shoulder Bag Messenger Handbags Casual Nylon Purse Handbag
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Large Lola Zipper Crossbody Tote
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs NOTAG Crossbody Bag for Women Waterproof Shoulder Bag Messenger Handbags Casual Nylon Purse Handbag
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Triangle Shoulder Bag
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs KARL LAGERFELD Women's Maybelle Choupette Crossbody
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Scenario Women's Hobo Handbag
- Naomi Shoulder Bag vs Camera Bag Purse
