Which tree looks more realistic?

The Douglas Fir. Its Feel Real tips are molded from real branches, and 1,867 tips fill it out far more than the Winchester Pine's 798.

Is the Douglas Fir worth more than double the price?

Only if realism and light count matter to you. At $355.09 versus $161.10, you pay about $194 more for denser tips, 350 more lights and a 3-year warranty.

Which tree is bigger?

Both are 6.5 ft. The Douglas Fir is listed at 49-59 in wide; the Winchester Pine at 48-52 in. The Douglas Fir is the fuller of the two.

Can either tree go outside?

The Winchester Pine is listed for indoor and covered outdoor use. The Douglas Fir is listed for indoor placement only.

Which has the better warranty?

The Douglas Fir, with 3 years on the tree and lights. The Winchester Pine listing states no warranty.

How long does setup take?

The Douglas Fir is listed at 45-60 minutes for its hinged, two-section assembly. The Winchester Pine is hinged too, and you shape the branches by hand after unboxing.

National Tree Feel Real Douglas Fir vs National Tree Pre-lit Winchester Pine

Buy the Winchester Pine if you want a 6.5 ft tree at the lowest price: $161.10 at Home Depot as of November 8, 2026, versus $355.09 at staples.com for the Douglas Fir. The Douglas Fir has the more realistic molded tips, more lights and a 3-year warranty, but at more than twice the price. Both are 6.5 ft National Tree Company pre-lit trees with clear incandescent lights that stay lit when a bulb fails.

Today the National Tree Feel Real Douglas Fir costs $25.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.