Which is better for pruning trees?

The Neo-tec. At about 8 lb with a 12-inch bar and a top handle, it is far easier to control one-handed on limbs. The Garvee's 20-inch bar and 58cc engine are overkill for branch work.

Which is better for cutting firewood?

The Garvee. Its 58cc engine and 20-inch bar buck logs that would stall the 25cc Neo-tec, and it costs less at $60.28 at Walmart.

Is the Garvee worth the extra power over the Neo-tec?

It is cheaper, not pricier: $60.28 versus $85.99. The trade-off is weight and bulk. If you cut logs over 8 inches, the Garvee is the better buy.

Can the Neo-tec fell a tree?

Only small ones. A 12-inch bar cuts through roughly 20 inches of diameter from both sides, but 1.2 hp makes it slow in hardwood. Use the Garvee for felling.

Neither has a published warranty here. A 58cc saw works less hard in big cuts, which usually means longer engine life; the Neo-tec lasts well if kept to light trimming and proper fuel mix.

Do both use the same fuel?

Yes. Both are 2-stroke gas engines and need gasoline mixed with 2-stroke oil. Neither includes fuel or bar oil.

Neo-tec NCS2500E 12in 25cc 25.4cc Top Handle Gas Chainsaw vs Garvee Gas Chainsaw, 20 Inch Gas Powered Chain saw, 58cc 2-Stroke Top Handle Chainsaw

Buy the Neo-tec NCS2500E if you need a light one-hand saw for pruning, limbing and in-tree work. Buy the Garvee 58cc if you are felling or bucking thick logs and want maximum power per dollar. The Neo-tec is $85.99; the Garvee is $60.28 at Walmart, down from a $100.28 regular price.

Ask our shopping agent