NewAge Classic Series Grill Island vs Brand-Man 6-Burner Gas Grill Island

Buy the NewAge Classic Series if you want a built-in island with a rotisserie and a stainless steel body that shrugs off weather. Buy the Brand-Man if griddle cooking and a big searing surface matter more than rotisserie. The NewAge is the heavier, more permanent piece at 630 lb with an aluminum frame and tempered glass panels; the Brand-Man is a lighter steel cart at about 163 lb. Owners of the NewAge style of island praise the solid feel and storage, while Brand-Man buyers like the 72,000 BTUs and six burners but note the lighter build and the extra cost of the natural gas conversion kit.

• Choose the NewAge Classic Series if you want a rotisserie, a side burner and a built-in island that stays put in the yard.
• Choose the Brand-Man if you want six burners, a 72,000 BTU sear and a griddle-friendly surface for big family cooks.