NewAge Classic Series 72-in Grill Island vs HomeMindful 82-Inch Outdoor Kitchen Island

Buy the HomeMindful if you want a complete cooking station out of the box: a 63,700 BTU five-burner grill, built-in refrigerator, sink and marble top on casters. Buy the NewAge if you want a modular, weatherproof cabinet system with a proven 304 stainless frame and a grill you can match to your own layout. The HomeMindful wins on cooking power and integrated appliances; the NewAge wins on build consistency, corrosion resistance and owner feedback, which is largely positive on quality and packaging. The HomeMindful is heavier, ships in two specialty packages and has little owner history to judge long-term durability.

• Choose the NewAge Classic Series 72-in island if you want a weather-resistant 304 stainless cabinet set with soft-close doors, adjustable levelers and a grill you can configure, and you value a track record of satisfied owners.
• Choose the HomeMindful 82-in stacked-stone island if you want one unit that already includes a high-BTU five-burner grill, refrigerator, sink and marble counter, and you can handle a heavy two-package delivery.