NightyNight 12" Queen Hybrid Mattress vs Ashley Furniture Augusta2 Queen Firm Mattress

The NightyNight is the better-documented hybrid: gel memory foam over individually wrapped coils, 12 inches thick, with CertiPUR-US foam and an OEKO-TEX cover, and it rates 4.3 from 339 owners. The Ashley Augusta2 is a firm wrapped-coil mattress with a stain-resistant, waterproof cover and a bed bug and dust mite barrier, which suits guest rooms and households with kids or pets. Both are firm; the NightyNight has more published detail on cooling, motion isolation and edge support, while the Ashley leans on its cover and its boxed delivery.

• Choose the NightyNight if you want a 12-inch hybrid with gel memory foam, pocket coils for motion isolation and a certified cover, and owner ratings you can read before buying.
• Choose the Ashley Augusta2 if you want a firm wrapped-coil mattress whose cover resists stains and water and blocks dust mites and bed bugs, and you can live with a 48-hour expansion wait.