Nike Air Monarch IV vs FitVille Men's Motionline V1

The Air Monarch IV is the safer pick for most men: a proven leather trainer with full-length Air cushioning, X-wide sizing and a long record of all-day comfort, though owners report squeaking and a thick tongue. The Motionline V1 is the better shoe for very wide feet and for anyone who wants a hands-free slip-on with a grippier outsole. The Monarch has the deeper review base and the more established build; the Motionline wins on width range and convenience.

• Choose the Air Monarch IV if you want a durable leather cross-trainer with Air cushioning, X-wide sizing and a long track record for walking, the gym and all-day wear.
• Choose the Motionline V1 if you need widths up to 4E, an arch-support insole and a step-in hands-free design for easy on and off.