Nike Everyday Cushioned Crew Socks 6-Pack vs Gold Toe 656S Cotton Crew Athletic Socks

Both are six-pair cotton crew athletic socks, so the choice comes down to fit and fabric. The Nike Everyday Cushioned has a higher cotton share and a ribbed arch band that holds the midfoot, but owners report it runs small and wears out faster than it used to. The Gold Toe 656S has more cotton, a reinforced toe and a wider 6-12.5 size range, which suits bigger feet; reviewers like its cushioning and stretch but flag quality-control misses like holes and uneven lengths. Buy the Nike for a snug, breathable sneaker sock in women's and mid sizes; buy the Gold Toe for full-cushion comfort and a tougher toe in larger sizes.

• Choose the Nike Everyday Cushioned if you want a lighter, more breathable crew sock with a supportive arch band for sneakers and gym work, and you fit its M size range.
• Choose the Gold Toe 656S if you have larger feet, want full cushioning and a reinforced toe, and prefer a higher cotton content.