Which is better for actually playing football?

The Wilson Duke. It is an official-size composite ball made for throwing and game use. The Nike Vapor is a leather collectible that scuffs quickly on turf.

The Wilson Duke. Composite leather holds up to regular play better than the Nike's natural leather, which shows wear fast.

Is the Nike Vapor worth stepping up to?

Only if you want a display piece. Its handcrafted leather and certificate of authenticity suit collectors and FSU fans, not players.

Does the Wilson Duke come with a warranty?

No. Wilson lists no written warranty on this replica model.

Is the Nike Vapor a full-size ball?

Yes. It is official size, but it is sold as a display and gifting item rather than a game ball.

Who should buy the Nike Vapor?

Seminoles fans, graduates and collectors who want a garnet-and-gold piece to display or gift.

Nike Vapor Football vs Wilson NFL Duke Replica Football

Buy the Wilson NFL Duke Replica for actual play and everyday throwing. It is an official-size composite-leather ball with a pebbled grip and a shape built for game use. The Nike Vapor is a display and collector piece: premium brown leather, handcrafted stitching and a certificate of authenticity, with a Seminoles logo that limits its appeal to FSU fans. Reviewers rate the Duke a solid 4.2 out of 5; the Nike is bought for looks and fandom, not for the field.

Choose the Nike Vapor if you want a garnet-and-gold Seminoles collectible to display, gift or keep boxed with its certificate.
Choose the Wilson Duke if you want a durable official-size ball to throw, practice with or play backyard games.

Prices

Nike Vapor Football: $49.99 at Amazon (checked today)
Wilson NFL Duke Replica Football: $49.99 at Target (checked today)
Difference: both cost the same today