Nike Shox Z Calistra Ballet Sneakers vs Tory Burch Ballet Sneakers

The Nike Shox Z Calistra is the bolder pick: a sporty Mary Jane with Shox columns and a buckle strap that reads as a statement piece. The Tory Burch Ballet Sneaker is the more conventional, dressier option, with a mixed nylon, suede and leather upper, a cork insole and a leather and nylon lining. Owners of the Nike call it cute and well made but split on comfort, with many finding it narrow and snug at the toe and rough for all-day wear. The Tory Burch has a laced fit that is easier to adjust and a cushioned cork footbed, but it is heavier and its mixed materials need more care.

• Choose the Nike Shox Z Calistra if you want a distinctive sporty Mary Jane look and will wear it for short stretches rather than long days on your feet.
• Choose the Tory Burch Ballet Sneaker if you want a laced, dressier ballet sneaker with a cork insole and leather lining that suits regular all-day wear.