Which is better for everyday wear?

The Dr Martens Buzz 5i. Its rubber sole, padded collar and Goodyear welt hold up to daily walking better than a manmade pump.

Which is better for a dressy outfit?

The Nine West Folowe. Its d'Orsay pointy toe fits day-to-night and formal outfits that a chunky lace-up does not.

The Dr Martens. Goodyear-welted leather and rubber outlast a manmade upper and sole, and the welt can be resoled.

Is the Nine West worth the price?

At $39.60 at Nine West as of October 28, 2026, it is a low-cost pump. Expect a shorter lifespan than a leather shoe.

Are either waterproof?

No. The Nine West is listed as not waterproof, and the Dr Martens hair-on leather is not described as waterproof either.

Which has better reviews?

The Dr Martens rates slightly higher at 4.8 of 5, but from only 63 ratings. The Nine West has 4.5 of 5 from 376 ratings.

Nine West Folowe Pump vs Dr Martens Buzz 5i

Buy the Nine West Folowe for a dressy, day-to-night pointed pump at a low price. Buy the Dr Martens Buzz 5i for a chunky, durable lace-up with real leather and rubber. The Nine West is listed at $39.60 at Nine West as of October 28, 2026. No current price was given for the Dr Martens, so compare its live store prices before deciding.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.