Ninja Creami vs Ninja Creami Deluxe 11-in-1 Ice Cream Maker

What separates them

Price history

• Ninja Creami: lowest $159.99 on Oct 28; $197.99 on Oct 29.
• Ninja Creami Deluxe 11-in-1 Ice Cream Maker: lowest $189.95 on Oct 29 at BuyDig.com; $189.95 on Oct 30.

Prices at every store

Specs compared

Questions and answers

Which makes better ice cream, the Creami or the Creami Deluxe?

Both use the same Creamizer paddle to shave a frozen base into a creamy texture, so results are close. The Deluxe adds programs like Frozen Yogurt and Italian Ice, and its larger pints suit bigger batches.

Is the Creami Deluxe worth the extra $30?

Yes if you want XL pints, 11 programs and the two-flavor split. No if you want a new unit with a 2-year warranty, since the Deluxe at $189.95 is refurbished.

How much ice cream does each make at once?

The original Creami uses 0.5 qt tubs and needs refreezing after about 3 pints. The Deluxe ships with two 24 oz pints holding 3 cups each, 50% more capacity per pint.

Do both need the base frozen overnight?

Yes. Both require at least 24 hours of pre-freezing before processing, then about 2 minutes to churn.

Which is quieter?

Neither. The original Creami is widely reported as very loud, and the Deluxe uses the same paddle design, so expect similar noise.

Which lasts longer?

The original Creami carries a 2-year warranty, while the Deluxe here is refurbished with warranty set by the seller. Some original units have been reported to break outside warranty.