Ninja Sizzle Pro XL Indoor Griddle vs Chefman All-Purpose Extra-Large Griddle

Buy the Ninja Sizzle Pro XL if you want one appliance that griddles and grills, holds steady heat up to 500°F, and swaps plates for different meals. Buy the Chefman if you mostly want a big flat surface for pancakes, eggs and bacon and value a long track record of owner satisfaction. The Ninja is the more capable machine with better temperature control and a detachable lid, but it is heavier and carries a shorter warranty. The Chefman is simpler, tops out at 420°F, has no removable plate, and its 5,377 ratings give it a much deeper reliability record than the Ninja's 213.

• Choose the Ninja Sizzle Pro XL if you want interchangeable griddle and grill plates, higher heat for searing, and a lid that speeds cleanup.
• Choose the Chefman 10" x 20" if you want a straightforward flat-top griddle with a dishwasher-safe surface and a large base of satisfied owners.