Which is better for a party of 10 or more?

The SLUSHi XL. Its 128-oz tank makes 10+ servings per batch, and it refreezes in as little as 15 minutes, so you can run back-to-back batches.

Is the XL worth $70 more?

If you host often, yes. You get 40 oz more capacity, faster freezing and two more programs for $319.00 at eBay versus $249.00 at Amazon, both as of November 5, 2026.

Which takes up less counter space?

The 5-in-1. It is 16.56 cm wide and 43 cm tall, against 21.8 cm wide and 50.2 cm tall for the XL.

No. Both freeze the liquid themselves. The 5-in-1 requires sugar in the mix to freeze properly.

How long do drinks stay frozen?

Both hold frozen drinks for about 12 hours, so you can leave a batch out through an evening.

Which is easier to clean?

The XL has a built-in rinse cycle. The 5-in-1 has dishwasher-safe parts. Both include a pour handle.

Ninja SLUSHi XL Frozen Drink Machine vs Ninja SLUSHi 5-in-1 Professional Frozen Drink Maker

Both are Ninja slush machines with the same 4.7 rating, so the choice comes down to batch size and speed versus price. The SLUSHi XL holds 128 oz (96 oz max fill, 10+ servings) and freezes in as little as 15 minutes; the SLUSHi 5-in-1 holds 88 oz (7+ servings) and takes up to 60 minutes. The XL is $319.00 at eBay and the 5-in-1 is $249.00 at Amazon, both as of November 5, 2026. Buy the XL for big parties and fast refills; buy the 5-in-1 to save $70 and get a smaller, lighter machine.

Today the Ninja SLUSHi 5-in-1 Professional Frozen Drink Maker costs $70.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.