Which is better for a beginner?

The Nocte. Its small size and rounded tip are easier to insert, and it is meant for short wear. The Maverick's 15 cm circumference is a big step up.

Which is better for hands-free use?

Both have suction cups. The Maverick adds a flared base and harness compatibility, so it works on a harness or a smooth surface. The Nocte is mainly a plug.

Which feels more realistic?

The Maverick. VixSkin dual-density silicone gives a soft outer layer over a firm core, with a shaped head. The Nocte is abstract and ridged.

Is the Maverick worth stepping up to?

If you want penetration or strap-on play, yes. It is a different product, not a bigger plug. For gentle anal wear, the Nocte is the better fit.

Which is easier to clean?

Both are silicone and clean with toy cleaner. The Maverick is fully submersible, which makes rinsing easier.

Nocte Silicone Butt Plug vs Vixen Maverick VixSkin Dildo

These are different tools, not close rivals. The Nocte is a small silicone plug with a suction cup, built for short, gentle anal wear. The Vixen Maverick is a realistic VixSkin dildo with a flared base, harness compatibility and a suction cup, built for penetration play and hands-free use. Buy the Nocte for a first plug or brief wear; buy the Maverick for a lifelike dildo you can mount or strap on.

Choose the Nocte if you want a small, soft silicone plug for gentle anal play and short wear.
Choose the Vixen Maverick if you want a realistic, harness-compatible dildo for penetration or hands-free suction-cup use.

Prices

Nocte Silicone Butt Plug: $48.56 at Melocotón Sensual (last seen Nov 11)
Vixen Maverick VixSkin Dildo: $121.72 at Amazon (last seen Nov 11)
Difference: the Nocte Silicone Butt Plug is $73.16 cheaper than the Vixen Maverick VixSkin Dildo at the latest prices (Nov 11)