Non-Iron Cotton Herringbone Button Down Collar Dress Shirt - White vs Charles Tyrwhitt Non-Iron Twill Dress Shirt

Both are non-iron white cotton dress shirts, but they suit different wardrobes. The Paul Fredrick shirt has a button-down collar with a full roll, a herringbone weave that adds visible texture, and a two-button adjustable cuff; owners call it soft, breathable and well made, though one 17-neck short ran very wide in the midsection. The Charles Tyrwhitt is a plain twill in a slim fit with stretch, so it reads cleaner and more modern and moves with you. Pick Paul Fredrick for texture and a structured collar; pick Charles Tyrwhitt for a trimmer, stretchier everyday shirt.

• Choose the Paul Fredrick herringbone if you want a white shirt with visible texture, a collar that holds its roll, and a softer, lighter hand than a classic dress shirt.
• Choose the Charles Tyrwhitt twill if you want a plain, slim-fitting non-iron shirt with a bit of stretch for long days at a desk.