Nordic Ware Microwave Splatter Cover vs NYTYU Glass Microwave Splatter Cover

Buy the NYTYU if you want a cover that won't stain, warp or hold odors, and you'll use it daily. Its borosilicate glass, silicone knob and two vent holes handle hot, greasy food better than plastic. The Nordic Ware is the lighter, cheaper-feeling option: BPA-free plastic, made in the USA, and top-rack dishwasher safe, but plastic covers eventually cloud, scratch and pick up smells. The NYTYU's 4.5-star rating from 23 ratings is a small sample, so treat it as a modest signal.

• Choose the Nordic Ware if you want a light, simple cover from a long-established US housewares brand and you don't mind plastic.
• Choose the NYTYU if you reheat greasy or strongly flavored food often and want glass that resists stains and odors.