Which is better for serious runners?

The Commercial 1750. Its 4.25 hp motor, 22 x 60 inch deck and RunFlex cushioning are built for running, and the -3% decline adds downhill work. The 1250's motor and deck size are not stated in the specs given.

Is the 1250 worth the lower price?

At $349.00 at Alpine Outlets as of November 7, 2026, it is far cheaper than a typical 1750 listing. You give up the large pivoting screen, the bigger deck and decline, so it suits walkers and lighter runners more than high-mileage runners.

Which has the better rating?

The 1250 rates 4.7 from 65 ratings; the 1750 rates 4.5 from 134 ratings. The 1750 has more than twice the ratings, so its score rests on more feedback.

Yes. Both are listed as foldable with a cooling fan, incline and heart rate monitor, and both top out at 12 mph.

Which holds more weight?

The 1250, at 300 lb versus 297 lb for the 1750. The difference is small.

Do I need an iFit membership?

The 1750 lists iFit as optional and not included. The 1250's membership terms are not stated in the specs given, so check before buying if you want guided workouts.

NordicTrack Commercial 1750 vs NordicTrack Commercial 1250 Treadmill

Both are NordicTrack Commercial treadmills with 12 mph top speed, incline, a fan, a heart rate monitor and a folding frame. The 1750 adds a 4.25 hp motor, a 22 x 60 inch deck, a 16-inch pivoting touchscreen, -3% decline and RunFlex cushioning, and it carries a 4.5 rating from 134 ratings. The 1250 is rated 4.7 from 65 ratings and is priced at $349.00 at Alpine Outlets as of November 7, 2026; no current price was given for the 1750. Buy the 1750 for serious running and decline training, and the 1250 if the lower listed price matters more than the bigger screen and deck.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.