Nostalgia Slushie Machine vs Ninja SLUSHi Frozen Drink Machine

The Ninja SLUSHi is the better machine for most shoppers. It freezes drinks itself with a compressor, holds 72 oz, keeps drinks frozen for up to 12 hours, and has a self-serve spout with temperature and texture controls. The Nostalgia is a small, simple ice shaver: you add ice and liquid, twist the lid, and a paddle stirs. It is lighter and easier to store, but it makes one small batch at a time and depends on ice you supply. Owners rate the Ninja much higher, and its build feels sturdier.

• Choose the Nostalgia Slushie Machine if you want a compact, lightweight shaver for an occasional small batch and don't mind adding your own ice.
• Choose the Ninja SLUSHi if you want hands-off frozen drinks, larger batches, a self-serve spout, and drinks that stay frozen for hours.