Which is better for a beginner?

The Bronco 18. It costs less, weighs less and comes with the rib hanging kit and multitool. Its airflow system is the same style as the Pro's, just on a smaller body.

Is the Bronco Pro 21.5 worth the extra money?

Yes if you cook for groups or do overnight brisket. The 17 lb. basket and larger grid cut down on refuels and give you more room. For two to four people, the Bronco 18 does the same job for less.

Which holds temperature longer?

The Bronco Pro 21.5. Its 17 lb. charcoal basket holds more than double the Bronco 18's 8 lb., so it runs longer between refuels. The Bronco 18 lists 14+ hours per session.

Can both smoke and grill?

Yes. Both run from low smoking heat up to 550 F for grilling. The Bronco 18 lists a low of 100 F; the Bronco Pro 21.5 lists 150 F.

How much cooking space do I get?

The Bronco 18 has 284 sq. in. on split grates. The Bronco Pro 21.5 uses a 21.5 in. round grid, roughly 363 sq. in., and fits about 16 burgers.

Which is easier to move?

The Bronco 18 is lighter at 136.5 lb. versus 162 lb. The Bronco Pro 21.5 has large wagon wheels built for rolling it around a patio.

Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 Drum Smoker vs Oklahoma Joe's Bronco Pro Drum Smoker

Buy the Bronco 18 if you want a compact drum smoker that smokes and grills for under $450. Buy the Bronco Pro 21.5 if you cook for crowds or want a bigger fire basket and heavier steel. As of November 7, 2026, the Bronco 18 is $448.57 at Amazon and the Bronco Pro 21.5 is $729.99 at Wayfair, about $281 apart.

Today the Oklahoma Joe's Bronco 18 Drum Smoker costs $281.42 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.