Which is better for a wedding guest?

The Old Navy fit and flare reads dressier, with puff sleeves and a full skirt. The LOFT shift is more casual and works better for daytime events.

Which works better for a pear shape?

The Old Navy fit and flare, because the skirt flares from the waist and balances wider hips. The LOFT shift falls straight and shows less waist definition.

Which is better in hot weather?

The LOFT dress. It is sleeveless and made of a cotton blend knit, while the Old Navy dress has puff sleeves.

Which packs better for travel?

The LOFT ruched knit. Knit fabric resists wrinkles, while a woven fit-and-flare skirt tends to crease.

Is the LOFT dress worth more than the Old Navy one?

Only if you want sleeveless knit and regular or petite sizing. Old Navy offers plus and tall sizes and a recorded price of $19.99 as of October 28, 2026.

Which has more size options?

Old Navy. It comes in regular, petite, plus, and tall; LOFT comes in regular and petite only.

Old Navy Fit & Flare Prairie Midi Dress vs LOFT Ruffle Double V Ruched Midi Dress

Buy the Old Navy Fit & Flare if you want a fuller skirt, sleeves, and the widest size range, including plus and tall. Buy the LOFT Ruffle Double V if you want a sleeveless, ruched knit dress that packs flat and skims the body. Old Navy's lowest price on record is $19.99 as of October 28, 2026; no LOFT price was given, so compare it at checkout.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.