Which is better for work?

The LOFT dress. It is marked for work, has cap sleeves, side slits and a solid modern knit. The Old Navy dress is sleeveless and floral, which reads more casual.

The Old Navy dress. It has sold as low as $6.00 and no higher than $14.97. The LOFT dress is $19.95 as of November 2.

Which has better ratings?

Old Navy, at 4.7 out of 5 from 131 ratings versus 3.9 out of 5 from 52 ratings for LOFT.

Which fabric is better for summer?

LOFT's cotton-modal-spandex knit is breathable and soft. Old Navy does not list fabric content, so check the label before buying.

Which fits more body types?

Old Navy, because it comes in regular, petite, plus and tall. LOFT does not list its size range.

Is the LOFT dress worth the extra money?

Yes if you need a work-appropriate knit with sleeves. Otherwise the Old Navy dress costs less and is rated higher.

Old Navy Fit & Flare Tie-Back Midi Dress vs LOFT Asymmetrical Ruched Midi Dress

Buy the Old Navy dress if you want a floral, fit-and-flare look for less; it is rated 4.7 from 131 ratings and has sold as low as $6.00. Buy the LOFT dress if you want a soft cotton-modal knit shift for work, but it is rated 3.9 from 52 ratings and costs about $19.95. On price, Old Navy wins clearly. On fabric and work-appropriate styling, LOFT wins.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.