Olivia Sofa vs Miller Brown Leather Sofa

The Miller is the better pick for small rooms, apartments and pet owners: genuine leather, a 750 lb capacity and a compact 85-inch frame. The Olivia is the better pick for lounging and for anyone who wants a deep, soft seat with feather-blend cushions and a choice of leather or fabric. Owners praise the Miller's leather and style but warn it sits low and firm, and one reported a smell on arrival. The Olivia's deep seats and feather wraps feel plusher, but feather cushions need regular fluffing and the larger footprint needs space.

• Choose the Olivia Sofa if you have room for a wide, deep sofa and want soft feather-blend cushions with a choice of leather or fabric.
• Choose the Miller Brown Leather Sofa if you want real leather in a compact footprint, need a high weight capacity, or have pets.