On Cloudsurfer Max vs Puma MagMax Nitro
Both are max-stack neutral trainers built for long, cushioned road miles, so the choice comes down to ride feel. The Cloudsurfer Max is the softer, smoother option, with a double layer of CloudTec Phase and Helion foam that rolls heel to toe and suits recovery runs and easy marathon miles. The MagMax Nitro is the bouncier, more propulsive shoe, with a 46mm/38mm stack of NITROFOAM and a PUMAGRIP outsole that holds up well on wet pavement. The On has very few ratings so far, while the Puma has a much larger owner base and a slightly lower average score.
- Choose the On Cloudsurfer Max if you want the plushest, most seamless rolling ride for high-mileage easy days and recovery runs.
- Choose the Puma MagMax Nitro if you want a livelier, springier max-cushion trainer with a grippier outsole and a longer track record with owners.
Prices
- On Cloudsurfer Max: $85.97 at Toptieta (checked today)
- Puma MagMax Nitro: $99.88 at Running Warehouse US (last seen Nov 13)
- Difference: the On Cloudsurfer Max is $13.91 cheaper than the Puma MagMax Nitro at the latest prices (Nov 13 and Nov 20)

