Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake vs Kate Farms Nutrition Shake

Both are organic, plant-friendly liquid shakes with 16g of protein, but they are built for different jobs. The Orgain is a lighter, lower-fat meal replacement with 20+ vitamins and minerals, 10 fruits and vegetables and a creamy texture; owners like the taste and convenience, though it carries 11g of added sugar and only 1g of fat. The Kate Farms is a denser oral supplement with 12g of fat and pea protein, aimed at people from age 1 up who need calories and nutrition support; it is the better pick for medically driven supplementation, while Orgain suits everyday breakfasts and snacks.

  • Choose the Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake if you want a creamy, lower-fat shake for breakfast, a snack or post-workout, and you are fine with some added sugar.
  • Choose the Kate Farms Nutrition Shake if you need a higher-fat, pea-protein supplement for a child or adult who needs extra calories and nutrition support.

Prices

  • Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake: $4.99 at Down to Earth Organic & Natural (last seen Nov 9)
  • Kate Farms Nutrition Shake: $4.99 at Optum Now (last seen Nov 9)
  • Difference: both cost the same at the latest prices (Nov 9)
Orgain
Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake

Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake

$4.99at Down to Earth Organic & NaturalChecked 15 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Down to Earth Organic & Natural
Pros
  • Creamy texture in chocolate and vanilla
  • 20+ vitamins and minerals plus fruits and vegetables
  • Lower fat at 1g per serving
  • USDA Organic, Non-GMO and gluten free
  • Convenient ready-to-drink meal replacement
Cons
  • 11g of added sugar per serving
  • Only 16g of protein and 1g of fat, so it may not keep you full long
  • Contains milk and whey, so not suitable for vegans despite plant-based positioning
Kate Farms
Kate Farms Nutrition Shake

Kate Farms Nutrition Shake

$4.99at Optum NowChecked 15 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Optum Now
Pros
  • Fully plant-based pea protein
  • Higher fat at 12g for calorie-dense nutrition support
  • No artificial sweeteners
  • Suitable from age 1 up
  • USDA Organic and kosher
Cons
  • Higher fat may not suit people watching fat intake
  • Pea protein texture and taste divide drinkers
  • Fewer declared vitamins and minerals than Orgain

What separates them

Orgain Organic Meal Replacement ShakeKate Farms Nutrition Shake
Protein sourceOrganic whey and grass-fed milk protein concentrateOrganic pea protein, fully plant-based
Fat per serving1g total, 1g saturated12g total
Added sugar11g added sugars from cane sugar and brown rice syrupNo artificial sweeteners; sweetened without cane sugar
Micronutrients20-21 vitamins and minerals plus a fruit and vegetable blendDesigned as a complete nutrition supplement, but fewer declared vitamins in the listing
Calories and satietyAbout 250 calories, light and drinkableDenser formula built to deliver more calories per serving
Who it is forBusy adults wanting a meal replacement or snackAges 1 year and up, pediatric to adult, for oral supplementation
CertificationsUSDA Organic, Non-GMO, gluten free, kosher, soy free, carrageenan freeUSDA Organic, kosher, gluten free, plant-based
Texture and formatCreamy ready-to-drink, sold in multipacksReady-to-drink, sold by the case

Price history

  • Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake: lowest $3.25 on Nov 10 at Lifeworks Store.
  • Kate Farms Nutrition Shake: lowest $4.60 on Nov 10 at Uber Eats.

Prices at every store

Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake

  • Down to Earth Organic & NaturalNew

    In stock

    $4.99Checked 15 h ago
    Visit Down to Earth Organic & Natural
  • ATC MedicalNew

    In stock

    $5.27+ $8.50 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit ATC Medical
  • MedicaleshopNew

    In stock

    $6.80+ $7.99 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Medicaleshop
  • Fruitful YieldNew

    In stock

    $4.29+ $17.85 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Fruitful Yield

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • Mothers Market & KitchenCheck price at Mothers Market & Kitchen
  • Strack & Van TilCheck price at Strack & Van Til
All 5 stores and price history →

Kate Farms Nutrition Shake

  • Optum NowNew

    In stock

    $4.99Free shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Optum Now
  • Honest MedicalNew

    In stock

    $6.46+ $7.99 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Honest Medical
  • Axiom MedicalsNew

    In stock

    $6.99+ $9.25 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Axiom Medicals
  • Family Care DMENew

    In stock

    $6.99+ $9.95 shippingChecked 15 h ago
    Visit Family Care DME

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon

Specs compared

SpecOrgain Organic Meal Replacement ShakeKate Farms Nutrition Shake
FlavorCreamy Chocolate Fudge, Sweet Vanilla BeanDessert Flavor, Chocolate Flavor
FormLiquidLiquid
Protein Grams Per Serving16g16 g
Typical UsersBusy professional, Athlete, ParentPediatric to Adult, Ages 1 Year and Up
Sugar Content11g (Added Sugars)No artificial sweeteners
Fat Content1g (Saturated Fat)12 g (Total Fat)
Number Of Servings121
Free OfGluten FreeGluten-free
Highlighted DietsPlant-Based, VeganPlant-Based
CertificationsUSDA Organic, Non-GMOKosher, USDA organic
Dietary InformationOrganicOrganic, Plant-based
Multipack Quantity4-packCase of 12
Show all 16 specsShow fewer specs
SpecOrgain Organic Meal Replacement ShakeKate Farms Nutrition Shake
Diet / Weight Loss SystemYes—
TextureCreamy—
Protein Type—Protein, Pea protein
Ingredients—Organic pea protein

What reviewers say

Orgain Organic Meal Replacement Shake

Drinkers praise the convenience, creamy texture and organic certification, and many use it as a fast breakfast or post-gym shake. The recurring complaints are the added sugar and a sweet, somewhat chalky taste.

What people mention
  • TasteMixedMany find the chocolate and vanilla flavors creamy and drinkable, while others call them too sweet or chalky.
  • SugarCriticisedDrinkers flag the 11g of added sugar as high for a drink they use daily.
  • ConveniencePraisedThe ready-to-drink bottle is praised for busy mornings and post-workout use.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers value the organic, non-GMO certification and the vitamin, mineral and produce blend.

Kate Farms Nutrition Shake

Reviewers generally appreciate the clean ingredient list and plant-based formula, but opinions are mixed on taste and texture. Some find it too sweet or chalky, while others rely on it for medical nutrition.

What people mention
  • TasteMixedSome reviewers enjoy the dessert-like flavors, while others find them overly sweet.
  • TextureCriticisedSeveral users mention a chalky or gritty mouthfeel.
  • IngredientsPraisedBuyers value the organic, plant-based formula without artificial additives.
  • ValueCriticisedMany consider it expensive compared to other nutrition shakes.

Questions and answers

Which is better for a quick breakfast?
Orgain. It is lighter at 1g of fat and about 250 calories, with a creamy texture and 20+ vitamins and minerals, which fits a fast morning meal better than the denser Kate Farms shake.
Which works better as a supplement for a child or older adult?
Kate Farms. It is formulated for ages 1 year and up as an oral supplement, with 12g of fat and pea protein for calorie-dense nutrition support.
Is either one vegan?
Kate Farms is plant-based with organic pea protein. Orgain uses organic whey and grass-fed milk protein, so it is vegetarian but not vegan.
Which has less sugar?
Kate Farms avoids cane sugar and artificial sweeteners. Orgain lists 11g of added sugars per serving from cane sugar and brown rice syrup.
Which keeps you full longer?
Kate Farms, because of its 12g of fat per serving. Orgain's 1g of fat and 16g of protein make it a lighter shake.
Is stepping up to Kate Farms worth it?
Only if you need a higher-fat, plant-based supplement for medical or calorie support. For everyday meals and snacks, Orgain covers more micronutrients with a creamier taste.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

All 6 stores and price history →