Casper Original Hybrid Mattress vs Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

The Signature Hybrid is the safer pick for most shoppers. It offers three firmness levels, a cooling cover and phase-change foam, and a much larger review base at 4.7 out of 5. The Original Hybrid is a solid medium-firm hybrid with zoned support and a strong 4.3 rating, but it gives you one feel and less temperature control. Owners of the Signature Hybrid praise cooling and support but report off-gassing and a springy feel; Original Hybrid buyers describe a soft-but-firm hug that does not sleep hot.

• Choose the Original Hybrid if you want a single medium-firm feel with 3-zone support and a cradling, hug-like surface for back, hip and shoulder pressure.
• Choose the Signature Hybrid if you want to pick soft, medium or firm, want active cooling, and value a long track record of owner reviews.