Orolay Cloak Puffer Down Coat vs Aritzia The Super Puff Shorty Jacket

The Orolay Cloak Puffer is the warmer, roomier, one-size option with a waterproof polyester shell and a lamb-wool-lined hood, and its cloak cut and oblique placket give it a distinctive look. The Aritzia Super Puff Shorty is the better fit for most shoppers: it comes in 3XS to 2XL across four lengths and over 20 colors, uses 700+ fill goose down, and carries a 4.9/5 editor testing rating. Orolay wins on weather protection and coverage; Aritzia wins on fit range, size consistency and finish. Buy Orolay for a long, hooded winter coat; buy Aritzia for a shorter, better-fitting jacket you can size precisely.

• Choose the Orolay Cloak Puffer if you want a long, hooded, waterproof coat with a distinctive cloak cut and don't mind a one-size fit.
• Choose the Aritzia Super Puff Shorty if you want a precise size, a shorter length and a choice of colors and finishes.