OXO Brew 12-Cup Coffee Maker vs Breville Precision Brewer

Both are SCA-certified 12-cup brewers with thermal carafes and precise temperature control, so the coffee quality is close. The OXO adds a podless single-serve basket for 2-4 cup brews, which the Breville lacks; the Breville counters with adjustable bloom time and flow rate, cold brew, and a narrower 6.7-inch footprint. Owners of the OXO frequently complain the carafe drips and traps water, while the Breville's main knock is a hand-wash-only carafe and no removable water tank. Buy the OXO if you brew single servings and full pots; buy the Breville if you want to tune the brew and have counter depth to spare.

• Choose the OXO Brew if you want one machine that does a 2-4 cup single serving and a full 12-cup pot, and you value the SCA certification and thermal carafe over brew-tuning controls.
• Choose the Breville Precision Brewer if you mostly brew full pots, want adjustable bloom time and flow rate plus a cold brew mode, and can live with hand-washing the carafe.