Which is better for hard ice cream?

The Zeroll. The mineral oil in its handle pulls warmth from your hand, which softens the ice cream at the bowl and helps the scoop release. The OXO's curved head also cuts firm ice cream, but it relies on force alone.

The OXO's stainless steel resists chipping, pitting and discoloring, and it is dishwasher safe. The Zeroll's aluminum alloy is corrosion resistant but hand-wash only, and the oil-filled handle can leak if the seal fails.

Is the Zeroll worth the extra $10?

If you scoop firm ice cream several times a week, yes. The self-defrosting handle makes the job noticeably easier. For occasional serving, the OXO at $12.99 does the job for less.

Can the Zeroll go in the dishwasher?

No. Zeroll says hand-wash only. Heat and detergent can damage the aluminum and the oil-filled handle.

Which gives rounder scoops?

The Zeroll. Its round 2 oz bowl produces the plump balls you see in ice cream parlors. The OXO's pointed head is built for scraping and cutting, so scoops come out less uniform.

Which is better for scraping a tub clean?

The OXO. Its flat edges reach into the corners of the container and scrape the sides. The Zeroll's round bowl leaves more behind.

OXO Good Grips Solid Stainless Steel Ice Cream Scoop vs Zeroll Original 2 oz Ice Cream Scoop

Buy the Zeroll Original if you scoop hard ice cream often and want round, easy-release scoops; its heat-conductive handle does real work. Buy the OXO if you want a dishwasher-safe scoop that scrapes containers clean for about $10 less. As of November 3, 2026, the OXO is $12.99 at Amazon and the Zeroll is $22.99 at eBay.

Today the OXO Good Grips Solid Stainless Steel Ice Cream Scoop costs $11.00 less at its best price.

Ask our shopping agent