OXO Pop Big Square Tall Container vs Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry

The OXO Pop Big Square Tall is the better pick for dry pantry staples like flour, cereal and pasta: its 5.7-liter square body holds a lot in a narrow footprint, and the one-touch pop lid seals tight and opens with one hand. The Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry is the more versatile container: it is microwave and freezer safe, leak resistant and stackable, so it handles leftovers and liquids as well as dry goods. Reviewers praise OXO's pop mechanism for easy, reliable sealing; Rubbermaid owners rate Brilliance around 4.2 out of 5, liking the clear body and latches but noting lids can be stiff.

• Choose the OXO Pop Big Square Tall if you mainly store dry staples in bulk and want a tall, narrow, one-hand-opening container that seals hard.
• Choose the Rubbermaid Brilliance Pantry if you want one container that also goes in the microwave and freezer, stacks, and resists leaks.