Ozark Trail Ultra Long Puffer Coat vs Orolay Thickened Down

The Orolay Thickened Down is the warmer coat: real duck down fill beats the Ozark Trail's recycled polyester insulation in serious cold. The Ozark Trail Ultra Long wins on coverage and wet weather, with a longer cut, water- and wind-resistant shell, and a removable hood. Owners of the Orolay praise its warmth-to-weight and roomy fit but note it runs large and the shell is only water-resistant in practice. Buy the Ozark Trail for slushy commutes and full-leg coverage; buy the Orolay for dry, bitter cold and a lighter feel.

• Choose the Ozark Trail Ultra Long Puffer if you want maximum length, a water- and wind-resistant shell, and a removable hood for wet, windy winters.
• Choose the Orolay Thickened Down if you want genuine duck down warmth in a lighter, mid-length coat for dry cold.