Douglas Parker Pigeon Plush vs Jellycat Strutton Pigeon

Both are small pigeon plush toys, but they are not equals. The Jellycat Strutton Pigeon is a New York City exclusive with a large, devoted following and far more owner ratings, so it is the safer pick for a gift or a collector. The Douglas Parker Pigeon is cheaper-feeling in the hand but adds a weighted bottom and machine washability, which matters for a toddler. For a child under three, buy Parker. For an adult collector or a Jellycat fan, buy Strutton.

• Choose the Parker Pigeon if you want a washable, weighted plush for a toddler or a low-commitment first pigeon.
• Choose the Strutton Pigeon if you want the Jellycat collectible, the NYC exclusive, or a gift with a known brand behind it.