Parkerfield Area Rug vs Herstmonceux Area Rug
Both are machine-woven polypropylene rugs made in Turkey, so the real differences are size, pile and color. The Parkerfield is the larger, slightly plusher rug with a muted greige farmhouse pattern and a much higher rating, though from only 14 reviews. The Herstmonceux is thinner, comes in a charcoal-led traditional palette, and has more reviews at a lower 4.4. No prices were given for either, so compare current store prices on Deal.ai before deciding.
Ask our shopping agent
Parkerfield Area Rug
4.9Choose the Parkerfield if you want a bigger rug (about 5'3" x 7'7") with a softer 0.37" pile and a neutral greige farmhouse look for a living room or bedroom.
- Higher rating, 4.9 from 14 ratings
- Slightly thicker 0.37" pile
- Larger footprint for a living room
- Neutral greige tones suit many decors
- Stain-resistant polypropylene, easy to spot clean
- Only 14 ratings
- Some buyers say it is thinner than expected
- Spec sheet conflicts on construction and material
- No backing, so a rug pad is needed on hardwood
What separates them
| Parkerfield Area Rug | Herstmonceux Area Rug | |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 100% polypropylene | 100% polypropylene |
| Construction | Machine woven in Turkey | Machine woven in Turkey |
| Pile height | 0.37" medium pile | 0.31" medium pile |
| Stated size | 160 x 230 cm (about 5'3" x 7'7") | 5'2" x 7' |
| Style and palette | Moroccan farmhouse geometric medallion in cream, beige and gray | Traditional Persian floral with charcoal, blush, teal and gold |
| Rating | 4.9 from 14 ratings | 4.4 from 33 ratings |
| Care | Vacuum regularly, spot clean with mild detergent | Hand wash only per listing; spot clean in practice |
| Certifications |
Price history
- Parkerfield Area Rug: lowest $108.00 on Oct 29.
- Herstmonceux Area Rug: lowest $39.00 on Oct 30 at Boutique Rugs.
Prices at every store
Parkerfield Area Rug
- PRHOMZCheck price at PRHOMZ
- Boutique RugsCheck price at Boutique Rugs
- Reckless & UnrulyCheck price at Reckless & Unruly
Herstmonceux Area Rug
- Plow & HearthCheck price at Plow & Hearth
- Lumberjack Direct, LLCCheck price at Lumberjack Direct, LLC
- Flatiron HomeCheck price at Flatiron Home
Specs compared
| Spec | Parkerfield Area Rug | Herstmonceux Area Rug |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | Hand-tufted | Machine Woven |
| Material | Jute/Sisal | 100% Polypropylene |
| Pile Height | 0.5'' | 0.31" |
| Made In | India | Turkey |
| Shape | Rectangle | Rectangle |
| Length | 7'3" | 2'11" |
| Width | 2'7" | 2'7" |
| Style | Farmhouse | Traditional |
| Pile Type | Medium Pile | Medium Pile |
| Placement | Indoor | Indoor |
| Thickness |
What reviewers say
Parkerfield Area Rug
With 14 ratings averaging 4.9 out of 5, owners mostly report the rug looks like the photos and holds up well. The main complaint is that it feels thinner than expected.
- Soft and plush underfoot
- Color matches the photos
- Good value for the price
- Durable and easy to spot clean
- Thinner than expected
Herstmonceux Area Rug
Rated 4.4 out of 5 from 33 ratings. Owners describe it as good value with colors that match the photos, and several note it holds up in high-traffic rooms. Complaints center on thinness, a temporary smell and the pink reading warmer in person.
- Colors match the photos well
- Soft enough underfoot for its pile height
Questions and answers
- Which is better for a living room?
- Both work. The Parkerfield is larger and slightly plusher, which suits a main seating area. The Herstmonceux lays flatter and layers well over another rug.
- Which lasts longer?
- Both are machine-woven polypropylene from Turkey with similar durability. The Parkerfield's thicker pile may mat faster in high traffic; the Herstmonceux's flatter pile resists crushing.
- Is the Parkerfield worth the extra?
- No prices were given for either, so check current store prices on Deal.ai. If they are close, the Parkerfield's higher rating and larger size favor it.
- Which is easier to clean?
- The Parkerfield: vacuum regularly and spot clean with mild detergent. The Herstmonceux listing says hand wash only, and buyers note professional cleaning.
- Which has better reviews?
- The Parkerfield rates higher at 4.9, but from only 14 ratings. The Herstmonceux has 33 ratings at 4.4, a larger and more mixed sample.
- Do either need a rug pad?
- Both have no backing, so a pad is recommended on hardwood to stop slipping and add cushion.
