Patagonia Black Hole Duffel 70L vs Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler Duffel 90L

The Black Hole 70L is the tougher, more weatherproof bag and the better pick for most travelers who want one duffel to last. The Cargo Hauler 90L wins on volume and internal organization, with dual end compartments, a divider and a padded base. Reviewers of the Black Hole praise its burly fabric, backpack straps and lifetime warranty; Cargo Hauler owners like the room and the carry options but note the bag is large and heavy when full. Pick by capacity and organization first, then by durability.

• Choose the Patagonia Black Hole 70L if you want a rugged, water-resistant duffel that carries like a backpack and is backed by Patagonia's lifetime repair warranty.
• Choose the Eagle Creek Cargo Hauler 90L if you need maximum volume with separate compartments for dirty gear and clean clothes on long trips.