StoreDeal.ai store
Shop
  • Deals
  • Deal checker
  • Black Friday
  • Buying guides
  • Brands
  • Stores
Travel
  • Flight deals
  • Hotel deals
Company
  • Research
  • Press
  • Use in AI assistants
  • Contact
  • deal.ai apps
Black Friday 2026
  • Walmart
  • Best Buy
  • Target
  • TVs
  • Laptops
  • Headphones
  • Apple
  • Gaming
  • Vacuums
  • Kitchen
  • Toys
  • Smartwatches
  • Tablets
  • Furniture
  • Mattresses
© Deal.ai Inc.·2222 Ponce de Leon Blvd, Miami, FL 33134·support@deal.ai
TermsPrivacy
Deal.ai › Compare

Patagonia Black Hole Backpack vs Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On

The Patagonia Black Hole is the better travel bag for most shoppers. It is lighter, opens wide for packing, has a padded laptop sleeve for 15-inch machines, and converts to a backpack. The Herschel Novel Duffle looks sharper and has a shoe compartment plus a trolley strap, but owners complain the top opening is small and the sides collapse. Reviewers rate the Black Hole higher on build and durability.

  • Choose the Patagonia Black Hole if you want a light, tough bag that opens wide, carries a 15-inch laptop, and can be worn as a backpack.
  • Choose the Herschel Novel Duffle if you want a classic-looking carry-on with a shoe compartment, a trolley strap, and a padded 13/14-inch laptop sleeve.

Prices

  • Patagonia Black Hole Backpack: $199.00 at Apex Outfitter and Board Co. (last seen Nov 20)
  • Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On: $39.99 at Herschel Supply Company (last seen Nov 20)
  • Difference: the Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On is $159.01 cheaper than the Patagonia Black Hole Backpack at the latest prices (Nov 20)
Patagonia
Patagonia Black Hole

Patagonia Black Hole Backpack

Patagonia Black Hole

$199.00at Apex Outfitter and Board Co.Checked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Apex Outfitter and Board Co.
Pros
  • Very light for its size
  • Wide opening makes packing and unpacking easy
  • Backpack straps free your hands
  • Recycled body, lining and webbing
  • Stuffs into its own pocket when empty
Cons
  • No trolley strap for sliding over luggage
  • Only a 15-inch laptop sleeve
  • Hand wash only
  • Some buyers find it costly
Herschel
Herschel Novel Duffle, Carry-On 26.5L

Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On

Herschel Novel Duffle, Carry-On 26.5L

3.9(34 ratings)
$39.99at Herschel Supply CompanyChecked 5 h ago
See all prices and details
Visit Herschel Supply Company

Store links may earn us a commission. Price via Klarna.

Pros
  • Classic duffle look
  • Separate shoe compartment
  • Trolley strap attaches to rolling luggage
  • Waterproof zippered closure
  • Limited lifetime warranty
Cons
  • Small top opening and collapsing sides
  • Fits only 13/14-inch laptops
  • Heavier than the Black Hole
  • Some owners report missing straps or tears on arrival

What separates them

Patagonia Black Hole BackpackHerschel Novel Duffle Carry-On
Opening and packingTop zipper opens wide to the full main compartmentSmall top opening; sides collapse and the bag will not stay open
Carry optionsPadded, removable shoulder straps let you wear it as a backpackRemovable padded webbing shoulder strap and low-profile handles only
Laptop fitSleeve holds most 15-inch laptopsPadded floating sleeve fits 13/14-inch laptops
WeightAbout 1 lb 6.6 ozHeavier; no weight listed
OrganizationZippered side pocket, mesh lid pocket, stuffs into its own pocketShoe compartment, zippered mesh pocket, side sleeve pocket
Luggage attachmentNo trolley strapRemovable trolley strap slides over a suitcase handle
MaterialsRecycled polyester with recycled TPU laminate, matte finishRecycled 600D polyester with waterproof zipper
Owner satisfactionBuyers praise capacity, weight and quality3.9 out of 5 from 34 ratings; complaints about the opening and a missing strap

Price history

$179.00$49.99
Nov 9Nov 21
  • Patagonia Black Hole Backpack: lowest $149.95 on Nov 21 at Amazon.
  • Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On: lowest $49.99 on Nov 21 at Herschel Supply Company.

Prices at every store

Patagonia Black Hole Backpack

  • HuckberryNew

    In stock

    $199.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Huckberry
  • Apex Outfitter and Board Co.New

    In stock

    $199.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Apex Outfitter and Board Co.
  • Index UrbanNew

    In stock

    $199.00Free shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Index Urban
  • Public LandsNew

    In stock

    $199.00+ $8.99 shippingChecked Nov 9
    Visit Public Lands

Also available at

  • AmazonCheck price at Amazon
  • PatagoniaCheck price at Patagonia
  • BackcountryCheck price at Backcountry

Store links may earn us a commission.

All 22 stores and price history →

Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On

  • Herschel Supply CompanyNew

    In stock

    $39.99+ $6.95 shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Herschel Supply Company
  • ZapposNew

    In stock

    $100.00Free shippingChecked 5 h ago
    Visit Zappos
  • Charles ClinkardNew

    In stock

    $118.10Checked 5 h ago
    Visit Charles Clinkard

Store links may earn us a commission. Some prices via Klarna.

All 3 stores and price history →

Specs compared

SpecPatagonia Black Hole BackpackHerschel Novel Duffle Carry-On
Dimensions18.8" x 11" x 5.9"11.75"(H) x 20.50"(W) x 11.00"(D)
Available Sizes40 L, 55 L, 70 L, 100 L—
Gear Capacity25L (1,526 cu in)—
Weight1 lbs 6.6 oz (640 g)—
Lining Fabric3-oz 200-denier 100% recycled polyester with a …—
Laptop Sleeveholds most 15" laptops—
Country of OriginMade in Vietnam.—
Care InstructionsHand Wash, Do Not Bleach, Drip Dry, Do Not Iron—
MaterialPolyester—
DepartmentMen's / Unisex—
Volume—43.0L
Main fabric—100% recycled 600D polyester, excluding trims
Show all 20 specsShow fewer specs
SpecPatagonia Black Hole BackpackHerschel Novel Duffle Carry-On
Liner material—100% recycled polyester
Closure—Waterproof zippered closure
Shoulder strap—Removable smooth webbing shoulder strap with EV…
Handles—Low profile vegan leather handles
Shoe compartment—Signature shoe compartment
Internal pocket—Zippered internal mesh pocket
Side pocket—Side sleeve pocket
Warranty—Limited Lifetime Warranty

What reviewers say

Patagonia Black Hole Backpack

Reviewers consistently praise the Black Hole's durability and rain resistance, and many use theirs for years of commuting and travel. Complaints center on the stiff material and the sparse internal organization.

What people mention
  • DurabilityPraisedOwners say the bag holds up for years of daily use and travel without tearing or fraying.
  • Weather resistancePraisedReviewers report contents staying dry in rain thanks to the coated shell.
  • Fabric feelMixedSome find the material stiff and noisy, while others see it as part of the rugged build.
  • OrganizationCriticisedUsers want more pockets and dividers for small items and cables.

Herschel Novel Duffle Carry-On

  • 3.9 / 534 ratings

Owners like the clean look, the build quality and the travel details, especially the trolley sleeve and laptop sleeve. The most common complaints are practical: the top opening is small, the sides fall in, and the bag feels smaller and harder to handle than expected.

What people mention
  • Opening and accessCriticisedOwners say the top opening is small, making it hard to pack, see inside and reach items.
  • StructureCriticisedThe soft sides fall in and the bag does not stay open on its own.
  • SizeMixedSome buyers say the size is accurate, while others find it smaller than expected.
Reviews
  • The Best Duffel Bags of 2026 - Reviews You Can Rely On
  • The Best Duffel Bags of 2025 - Reviews You Can Rely On

Questions and answers

Which is better for carry-on air travel?
The Herschel Novel has a trolley strap and a shoe compartment, which suit short trips. The Black Hole packs faster thanks to its wide opening and carries a larger laptop. For most travelers the Black Hole is the easier bag.
Which holds a bigger laptop?
The Black Hole sleeve fits most 15-inch laptops. The Herschel sleeve fits 13/14-inch models. If you carry a 15-inch machine, pick the Black Hole.
Which is easier to carry through a airport?
The Black Hole converts to a backpack, so your hands stay free. The Herschel rides on a shoulder strap or handles, or on your rolling suitcase via the trolley strap.
Which lasts longer?
Both use recycled polyester. The Black Hole's TPU laminate and matte finish resist abrasion well, and owners praise its quality. The Herschel carries a limited lifetime warranty, but some buyers report tears on arrival.
Is the Herschel worth stepping up to over the Black Hole?
Only if you want the duffle look, a shoe compartment, and a trolley strap. The Black Hole wins on weight, opening, laptop size, and owner ratings.
Can the Black Hole be used as a gym bag?
Yes. It stuffs into its own pocket when empty and has a zippered side pocket for small items. The Herschel's shoe compartment is handier for dirty shoes.

Ask our shopping agent

It checks today's price at every store, compares the alternatives and answers in about a minute.

Enter to send, Shift+Enter for a new line

More comparisons

  • Patagonia Black Hole vs Under Armour Undeniable 5.0 Duffel LG
  • The North Face Base Camp Waterproof Duffel 50L vs Patagonia Black Hole
  • Nemo Double Haul vs Patagonia Black Hole
  • The North Face Base Camp Voyager Duffel vs Patagonia Black Hole
  • Patagonia Black Hole vs Eagle Creek Migrate
  • The North Face Base Camp Waterproof Duffel 50L vs Herschel Novel Duffle, Carry-On 26.5L
  • Under Armour Undeniable 5.0 Duffel LG vs Herschel Novel Duffle, Carry-On 26.5L

Buying guides that pick them

  • Best rectangular duffel bags
  • Best duffel bags
  • Looks and buildPraisedBuyers call it clean and classic and rate the quality as very good.